I was doing some preliminary research for a project when I came across this sentence:
So she went to the local community college and remembers that in some way she had become "less ambitious than when I was younger."
The first thing I noticed was the pronoun disagreement, but since I've not had any formal grammar training since 8th grade and wanted to be sure my suspicions about how to use brackets were accurate, I passed on the sentence to the trusty Green, asking if it was correct. Her response:
Absolutely not. I don't know where this writer got a degree, or what the copyeditor was thinking. Mixing up tenses and subject-verb agreement is something you should expect to get right by the time you leave elementary school. It should run:
So she went to the local community college and remembered that in some way she had become "less ambitious than when [she] was younger."
And even that is a sloppy sentence. This is why I quit journalism.
I busted out laughing when I realized that, in addition to the pronoun disagreement, the author managed to squeeze present tense, past tense, and past perfect all in one sentence. This was not just some blog post (I'm certainly not innocent there). This was a report of an empirical study, published in a peer-reviewed journal. What does that say about those who call themselves scholars?
How important is grammar, really? Should it be a basic expectation in any kind of scholarly communication? I think so, but I also feel that the disregard for correctness in writing in all places is diminishing the beauty of written communication. The above example is from 1995, so it has nothing to do with texting, tweeting, or internet communication in general. But Web 2.0 is certainly not helping the problem, when a blogger's foremost credential is how many readers they persuade to return from day to day.
So is the English language in danger? Probably not any more than it was when "ain't" was added to the dictionary. But such a disregard for quality writing--and editing--still irks me sometimes.
Oh, well. Some rules are stupid anyway, as evidenced by the frequent use of the "
singular their" by Austen, Shakespeare, The King James Bible, and many many others.